The Citizen’s Verdict: Why Shoddy Workmanship and Broken Systems Will Haunt the Government at the Ballot Box

Elected representatives often fall into a dangerous trap: they look at a single complaining citizen and think, "It's just one person. We can tune them out, and it won't matter."


Let me just suggest to our Members of Parliament and administrators to review your positions:  My influence affects more people than you think. When I approach you, I am not just asking you to fix a minor inconvenience or even my problem; I am bringing to you  people’s issues so that you can fix the very systems and mindsets  that create these problems, or repeat again unless the organisation, agency or department is reshuffled or overhauled. This is the reform we are expecting to see.


If you continue to turn a deaf ear to the grassroots, like what Selangor Pakatan government has done to my blog Surat Terbuka kepada Menteri Besar, originally meant to show the state Adminstration how lackadaisical attitude of local couuncils have affected our livelihood, do not be surprised when word spreads through coffee shops and viral messages, returning to haunt you at the next general election (PRU16). Read here and here.


Voters might have looked past your flaws in the last election, but their patience is not infinite.


Here is my honest breakdown of how some of our current leadership is handling—and mishandling—the everyday experiences of regular Malaysians.


1. Anthony Loke (Minister of Transport) The Issue: KTM Berhad (KTMB) poor customer mindset 


I personally brought an issue regarding KTMB directly to the Minister of Transport, Anthony Loke. While an isolated breakdown or delay, or in my case, a sheer denial of is ETS tickeing system, might seem like a mere symptom to an outsider, but a minister must understand that it points to a systemic failure.


The Lesson: We don't just need a quick fix for today's problem. We need the system itself overhauled. When you fix the system (read here), it automatically resolves the issue for me and every future commuter who relies on KTMB.


2. Hannah Yeoh (MP for Segambut)

The Issue: DBKL’s Deteriorating Road Work


This is another good example. While I consider her a good minister overall, the way DBKL roadworks are carried out right now is highly disappointing.


Compare her tenure to when Dr. Zaliha Mustafa and Dr. Seri Maimunah were managing the Federal Territories—the drop in standards is stark.


After several rounds of WhatsApp to Aduan Potholes DBKL and whispered to her and the mayor, DBKLrepaired this section of the road half-heartedly. You can see the shoddy work done; although one lane is repaired, holes on the other lane are left unattended. Tan Sri Ketua Setiausaha Negara (KSN) should be aware of this and it may be time to relocate the underperforming  staff to a different council far, far away. Sacking may be necessary if they continue to underperform.


It is not only Jalan Segambut that is in terrible condition. Today, if you drive along Jalan Lang Mas or Jalan Bukit Maluri, you will find yourself fuming at the potholes and uneven surfaces. As I understand it, DUKE concessionaire has not handed over the road back to DBKL, and this requires the mayor as as well as the Malaysia Highway Authority under minister of works, Alexander Nantha Linggi’s attention. Anyone wanting to speak to thr press, let me know. We do not want to flog a working horse but if I only see the condition of the road without knowing what transpired after my time-consuming whispers, even I would lose my patience.


Contrast this with Petaling Jaya, where such shoddy roads are virtually non-existent.


When I brought this to Hannah Yeoh, it wasn’t to turn her into a literal pothole patcher. It was to expose the shoddy workmanship being executed by DBKL staff right under her nose. While I can understand ministers receive many hundreds of messages, just an icon to acknowledge the time and efforts I had taken, is not too difficult but hardly any response, or corrective measure taken, is simply concerning. 


The Responsibility: As the leader, she needs to call up the Pengarah (Director) and sound them out.

The Solution: If DBKL’s senior management is sabotaging the good intentions of the Madani government through sheer neglect, they must be reshuffled or relocated immediately.


3. Teresa Kok (MP for Seputeh)

The Issue: A 22-Year-Old Without an Identity Card (IC)


I encountered a heartbreaking case of a 22-year-old youth with no IC, a situation causing massive complications for his family. Hoping to prevent a family from being torn apart, I approached Teresa Kok, expecting a long-serving lawmaker to fight for her constituent.


Instead, she showed zero patience, abruptly telling the youth to contact her personal assistant. To my absolute shock, the assistant later told us, "And no appointment given to meet YB Teresa. Alice mentioned that because he is 22 years old, unlikely he is able to get application through.” When pressed, the MP herself defended her stance by saying, "i don't need to meet this guy cos i can't give approval." 🙄


This is easily one of the most ridiculous and dismissive statements ever uttered by a lawmaker. No one is asking her to personally stamp and approve an IC—since when do individual MPs hold that constitutional power anyway?


The Reality: She is an elected representative. Her job is to understand the issue and advocate for her people.


The Missed Opportunity: She should have used her position to liaise with the Minister of Home Affairs, Saifuddin Nasution, to find a compassionate, legal resolution for this family. To hide behind bureaucratic semantics is a total failure of duty. Malaysians will not be able to expect any reform where the entire service when lawmakers continue to ignore the symptoms brought to the 

attention and not fix the mindsets and the very systems that caused the problems to recur — today to me, tomorrow to some others. If this is a human resource issue, the chief secretary, Tan Sri Shamsul Azri Abu Bakar is in a good position to do what is necessary.


KSN Tan Sri Shamsul Azri

I could share a wealth of insights regarding my Member of Parliament in Damansara and various Selangor state executive councillors—including my personal encounters with them. Suffice it to say, our interactions have always been perfectly amiable, until I see I see they are totally detached from their surroundings.


I have throughout this blog given credit to whom credit is due but one thing that touched my heart recently is the good example set by out prime minister’s own wife. 


4. Dr. Wan Azizah Wan Ismail (MP for Bandar Tun Razak)

The Standard of True Leadership

Thankfully, true public service isn't entirely dead. In Bandar Tun Razak, a lady faced repeated rejections when applying for welfare (kebajikan). Dr. Wan Azizah stepped in, but her special officer Kuek Zhe Han didn’t just stop at helping with paperwork.


In an impromptu, unannounced surprise, Dr. Wan Azizah sent food supplies through her special officer to this constituent—simply to remind her that her years of social contribution to the welfare and rehabilitation of female drug addicts were appreciated and not forgotten.


There was no camera crew, no TikTok dance, and no social media boasting. I am highlighting this on a pro bono basis because this is the exact blueprint every elected representative should emulate. 


Despite her quiet posture, Dr. Wan Azizah demonstrates what a true Member of Parliament looks like.


The Ultimate Takeaway

To the politicians currently sitting comfortably in your offices: it does not matter how many grand policies you debate in Parliament if the local government's work remains shoddy. 


People live their lives on the ground. Broken facilities, hazardous potholes, dark streets without lamps, and cold bureaucratic rejections are what shape their daily reality.


When you detach yourselves from these grassroots struggles, you detach yourselves from your voters. Another example is the way how SelangorState Planning Guidelines and Standards for Community Facilities which will affect future Non-Muslim places of worship  once gazetted. Read here.


If politicians keep ignoring our complaints, do not be surprised when voters refuse to show up for your political dramas at the next PRU. Worse, they and their communities will reject you!



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

DAP needs reforms, too

Image
I am writing with tongue-in-cheek to prompt the DAP leadership to do some serious re-thinking about their decision whether to remain or stay out of Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's cabinet.  Giving the prime minister to deliver reforms within six months was a convenient way to pass on the blame to the prime minister after the defeat of the DAP in Sabah.  Anthony Loke would likely have already been part of the DAP during the period when the party, led by its two stalwarts Lim Kit Siang and Karpal Singh, suffered a major setback in the Tenth General Election in 1999. That election marked one of the most humiliating defeats in DAP’s history, as both leaders—long regarded as politically invincible—were unseated in the constituencies they contested: Karpal Singh as Chairman and Lim Kit Siang as DAP Secretary-General. DAP has a history of withdrawing from the coalition Barisan Alternatif that they joined. In the context of marriage, DAP has to learn that a marriage vow includes "For ...
Read more

Menteri Pengangkutan, di mana reform ke atas KTMB?

Image
Kita perlu pastikan KTMB dirombak sebelum budaya kerja teruk sehingga menjadi seperti di sesetengah negara. Itu sebab MRT /LRT/ ECRL tidak boleh disatukan di bawah penyeliaan KTMB Sejak tahun 2005 lagi, saya telah mula mempromosikan penggunaan keretapi Komuter kepada pelajar-pelajar institusi pendidikan tinggi (IPT) tapi sehingga kini, nampaknya sikap dan budaya kerja KTMB masih tak berubah langsung.  Kalau dulu, memang krew TV3 ikut saya untuk membuat highlight tentang perkhidmatan yang dialami setiap hari oleh pelanggan setiap hari seperti tren lambat sampai atau kadang-kadang kami diberitahu perjalanan tren terpaksa ditangguhkan kerana rosak. Lepas itu, pandai-pandailah cari cara pergi kerja sendiri, naik bas atau ambil teksi itu masalah pelanggan sendiri kerana tren rosak dan tidak ada tren penggantinya. Begitulah masalah-masalah yang dihadapi oleh pelanggan KTMB dulu dan sekarang juga. Sikap kakitangan KTMB harus berubah sekarang. Jika tidak KTMB akan terus ketinggalan. Janga...
Read more

From Hak Milik Sementara to Geran

Image
  What you should be getting is Geran (above), not  Hakmilik Sementara (below) Housebuyers are usually very ignorant. They are issued Qualified Titles, not it should be -- the Title Deed or Grant.           For this discussion, we will only focus on Geran and Hakmilik Sementara. It is not the 99-year-old lease title or freehold title. Please don't talk about this in this blogpost. Leasehold and Freehold is a state matter, not a federal issue that the Minister can handle.           Look at your document to see if you have the words 'Hakmilik Sementara' or 'Geran.' This is important.           'Geran' means that the title is complete. 'Hakmilik Sementara' means that your developer has not carried out the survey yet or submitted the survey to the Land Office so that your individual titles (or 'Geran') can be issued. Because the Survey has not carried out yet, the title issued to you is 'Hakm...
Read more